01What an appraisal policy is for, and who it covers
An appraisal serves three different purposes, and most companies mix them: measuring past performance, identifying development needs, and building decisions on pay and confirmation. Mixed together, the employee defends his score instead of learning from it. The policy separates them: the review cycle measures, the interview record plans development, and the pay decision is made by a separate authority after the result is approved, not before.
HR drafts it with department heads and the general manager approves it. It covers permanent employees after probation on an annual cycle, and employees at the end of probation through a special review. It does not cover seasonal contractors engaged for under [__] months. It does not deal with violations and penalties, which have their own separate policy.
02The performance appraisal policy text and the interview record form
[Company name] Employee performance appraisal policy Version: [number] Effective date: [date] 1. Purpose and scope 1.1 This policy regulates the periodic measurement of employee performance against announced criteria, and links the result to development, confirmation and reward. 1.2 It applies to permanent employees after probation, and to those finishing probation through a special review. 2. The review cycle 2.1 An annual review cycle runs from [month] to [month], and HR announces its title and date [__] days before it starts. 2.2 A half-yearly cycle may be run for groups that management specifies. 2.3 The manager and the employee hold a goals check-in every [__] months between cycles. 3. Criteria and weights 3.1 HR sets the criteria for each group and their weights before the cycle starts, and the weights total 100. 3.2 Each criterion has an announced scale (1 to 5, 1 to 10, or yes and no). 3.3 Criteria and weights are not changed once the cycle has started. 3.4 The employee is told the criteria for his appraisal and their weights at the start of the cycle. 4. Reviewers 4.1 The employee is assessed by his direct manager, and a peer, the manager's manager or HR may take part as the cycle specifies. 4.2 No one assesses an employee with whom he has a documented personal dispute or a family tie. 4.3 A reviewer must complete his assessment on time, and HR reminds him before the deadline. 5. Self-appraisal and 360 review 5.1 The employee assesses himself on the same criteria, and his self-appraisal carries a weight of [__]% (up to 50%). 5.2 A cycle may include an anonymous 360 review weighted [__]% (up to 30%), whose result is not shown unless at least three reviewers took part. 6. Calibration and approval 6.1 HR reviews each reviewer's distribution of scores and calibrates anyone who departs from the cycle mean by more than [__] points. 6.2 A final score is changed only for a written reason, with a record of the score before and after. 6.3 Management approves the results after calibration, and they are not changed after approval. 7. Result bands 7.1 Outstanding: 90 to 100. Strong performance: from 75. Meets expectations: from 60. Developing: from 40. Needs improvement: below 40. 8. The interview and the employee's acknowledgement 8.1 Within [__] days of the result being approved, the manager holds an interview with the employee and records strengths, areas to improve and development goals. 8.2 The employee sees his result and acknowledges having read it, and may record a reservation in writing within [__] days. 8.3 The acknowledgement is knowledge of the result, not agreement with it. 9. What follows from the result 9.1 A result of "needs improvement" leads to an improvement plan with a period and written expectations. 9.2 Raises and bonuses are considered in light of the result, and the decision belongs to whoever holds financial authority. 9.3 An end-of-probation result carries a confirmation recommendation, and the decision belongs to HR. 10. Confidentiality of results 10.1 Results are kept in the employee's file, and only he and those who need it for their work may see them. Approval [Approver name and title] Signature: ________ Date: [date] -------------------------------------------------- Appraisal interview record Employee: [name] Employee no.: [number] Cycle: [title] Reviewer: [name and title] Interview date: [date] Final result: [score] Band: [band] Strengths: [__] Areas to improve: [__] Development goals (up to eight): [__] Employee's remarks: [__] Reviewer signature: ________ Employee's acknowledgement of reading: ________ Date: [date]
03The policy clause by clause
Clause 3: criteria and weights are announced before, not after
Nothing destroys an employee's trust in an appraisal faster than discovering, after the result, that a criterion he never knew about carried the biggest weight. So criteria and weights are set before the cycle starts, not changed afterwards, and the employee is told of them at the beginning. Advice on choosing them and their weights is in the article on annual review criteria and weights.
Clause 4: three kinds of reviewer
The direct manager sees results, a peer sees cooperation, and HR sees compliance. Combining them softens the bias of any one reviewer. The condition that no one assesses someone with whom he has a documented dispute or a family tie protects the cycle from its first objection.
Clause 5: self-appraisal with a cap, 360 with confidentiality
Self-appraisal makes the employee a partner in the conversation, but its weight is limited so that it does not become a score he awards himself. An anonymous 360 review helps when the number of reviewers is large enough to hide who wrote a comment, which is why its result is not shown without three reviewers.
Clause 6: calibration for a written reason
One lenient manager gives everyone 95 and a strict one gives them 60, and the two teams cannot be compared. Calibration corrects this by checking each reviewer's mean and deviation, and no figure is changed by it without a reason that is written and kept.
Clauses 7 and 8: the bands and the acknowledgement
A band translates the number into words the employee understands, and its limits are announced. The acknowledgement means knowledge and not agreement, and the employee may record a reservation, because a result on which the employee is not heard turns into a quarrel. The biases that affect appraisals, and how to prevent them, are covered in bias in performance reviews.
Clause 9: the result is a suggestion, not a decision
An improvement plan, a raise and confirmation are decisions taken by a person with authority, and the result is one of their reasons. Linking a raise automatically to the result tempts people to adjust the score for the sake of a raise or to avoid one. The link between appraisal and raise is covered in raises and bonuses from a performance review.
04A worked example: one employee's score on the "General employee" model
The example is a review cycle using the program's ready "General employee" model, whose weights are six criteria totalling 100. The scores out of 100 are illustrative inputs, the criterion weights come from the program's catalogue, and the self-appraisal and the band are combined with the program's own functions:
| Criterion | Group | Weight | Score | Contribution |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| جودة العمل ودقته | الجودة | 20 | 85 | 17 |
| الإنتاجية وإنجاز المهام في وقتها | الجودة | 20 | 90 | 18 |
| الالتزام بمواعيد الدوام والتعليمات | السلوك | 15 | 70 | 10.5 |
| التعاون مع الفريق | السلوك | 15 | 80 | 12 |
| المبادرة وتحمّل المسؤولية | السلوك | 15 | 100 | 15 |
| التطور والتعلم المستمر | النمو | 15 | 75 | 11.25 |
The contributions total 83.75, so the reviewer's score rounds to 84, in the band "أداء قوي". If the employee submitted a self-appraisal of 90 with a weight of 20% of the cycle, the final result would be 85, worked out as (100 − 20)% of the reviewer's score plus 20% of his own, in the band "أداء قوي". Had he not submitted a self-appraisal, it would stay at 84 with a note shown to him giving the reason.
05When not to apply this policy
An employee on probation
He does not enter the annual cycle. He has an end-of-probation review on its own model, and the decision to confirm or end his employment belongs to HR.
Performance whose cause is a violation
When the weakness is behaviour that breaches the regulations (repeated absence, ignoring instructions), it belongs to the penalties chapter and not to appraisal. Refer to the disciplinary actions policy and do not lower the score as a punishment.
An employee who spent part of the cycle on long leave
He is not assessed for a period he did not work. Write a minimum period of actual work in the cycle, and defer the review of anyone below it.
An appraisal used on its own for dismissal
One result is not enough reason to end employment. Ending it has its own procedures and regulated grounds, and a written improvement plan built on the result precedes it and is not replaced by it.
06Hard cases and common mistakes
A new manager assessing a team he has worked with for two months
Let him take part alongside the previous manager or colleagues, and write a minimum supervision period after which he becomes the main reviewer.
Two employees whose scores sit either side of a band limit
The limit divides 74 from 75, say. Explain in the interview that the difference is one point and that the band is read with the detail, not alone.
An employee who objects to every result
Do not stop him recording a reservation. Record it, have the objection reviewed by someone other than the reviewer, and close the cycle.
Common mistake: every score in the top band
When everyone gets 90 or more, the appraisal means nothing. Ask reviewers to justify high scores with facts, and review the distribution in calibration.
Common mistake: one review a year with no follow-up
Hearing in January about what happened in February is no use. Put a short goals check-in between cycles.
07Steps to adapt the policy to your company
- 1
Start from a ready model and then adjust it
Choose the model closest to your jobs and change two or three criteria to reflect your work. Writing the model from scratch consumes months.
- 2
Fix the weight of self-appraisal and the 360 before announcing
A weight of zero makes it for information only, and every increase gives the employee more say in his own score.
- 3
Write the interview and reservation deadlines
How many days after approval for the interview, and how many days to record a reservation.
- 4
Name who calibrates and who approves
Make them two different people so that no one reviews himself.
- 5
Pilot the cycle on one team first
A team of ten shows what the text misses: an unclear criterion, or a reviewer who is late.
08Appraisal policy checklist before approval
8 items
09Frequently asked questions
This template does not set a mandatory number. A yearly cycle with a goals check-in every three months is common, and a company may choose another rhythm to suit its work.
Quality of work, completing tasks on time, keeping to working hours and instructions, teamwork, initiative and development. Sales, operations and management each have criteria of their own. See criteria and weights.
The company decides, and it is better for the result to be one reason for the decision than an automatic rule. The detail is in raises and bonuses from a performance review.
He records his reservation in writing within a set period, someone other than the reviewer looks at it, and the approved result stands until it is changed for a written reason.
A period with written expectations, tasks with deadlines and follow-up, ending in a decision: passed, extended or not passed. The detail is in the performance improvement plan.
No. They are kept in the employee's file, and only he and those who need them for their work may see them.
