01What a job evaluation policy is for, and who it covers
The policy aims to price jobs by an objective measure of what they require, so that two similar jobs differ in pay only by a written criterion such as experience or performance. It applies to the permanent jobs in the company, and it includes creating a new job and a material change in the duties of an existing one.
The job is evaluated, not its holder. An employee's performance and competencies belong to the appraisal policy and the competency framework. This policy asks: what is a job with these duties and responsibilities worth? It is tied to job descriptions, because the evaluation rests on a written description. It does not change the basic pay of an existing employee by automatic decision, since placing someone is for management to decide.
02The job evaluation policy text
[Company name] Job Evaluation Policy Version: [number] Effective date: [date] 1. Principle 1.1 Every job is evaluated by what it requires in knowledge, responsibility and conditions, whoever holds it. 1.2 A job's evaluation is not changed because its holder is outstanding or weak, which the annual appraisal deals with. 2. Factors and weights 2.1 A job is evaluated on four factors: knowledge and skill, problem solving, responsibility and impact, and working conditions. 2.2 The weight of each factor is: [__]%, [__]%, [__]% and [__]%, totalling 100%. 2.3 Each factor is rated from 1 to 5 by the attached description of each level, and no rating is accepted without a written justification. 3. Points and grades 3.1 A factor's points = its weight x its rating, and the sum of the points is the job's points. 3.2 Points are turned into a grade by the approved scale: [Grade 1: from __ to __], [Grade 2: from __ to __], and so on. 3.3 Two jobs with the same points are in one grade, even if the department differs. 4. The pay range of each grade 4.1 Each grade has a minimum, a maximum and a midpoint for basic pay, which management approves and reviews yearly against the labour market. 4.2 Each employee's pay is compared with the midpoint of his grade's range: ratio = pay / midpoint. 4.3 Pay outside the range (above the maximum or below the minimum) is raised to [body] with a written reason. 5. Placement and hiring 5.1 A new employee is hired within the range of his job's grade, and management may allow an offer below the minimum according to experience and with a written reason. 5.2 The offer made to a candidate does not exceed the pay of a colleague in the same job with the same experience without a written reason. 5.3 Moving an employee to a job of a higher grade is followed by a fresh decision on his pay within the new grade's range. 6. The committee and review 6.1 The evaluation is carried out by a committee of [HR, a direct manager and a representative of senior management], which keeps minutes for every job. 6.2 Job evaluations are reviewed when a job is created, when its duties change materially, or every [__] months. 6.3 The holder of a job may ask for its evaluation to be reviewed by a written request with his reasons, and he is answered in writing within [__] days. 7. Confidentiality 7.1 The grade scale and its ranges are internal information, and only what management decides is announced. 7.2 No one sees an employee's pay unless he needs to. 8. Records 8.1 Evaluation cards, committee minutes, the grade scale and its ranges, and the date of every change to them are kept. Approval of the policy [Approver's name and title] Signature: ________ Date: [date] -------------------------------------------------- Job evaluation card Job: [title] Department: [department] Date: [date] Committee: [members] Factor | Weight | Rating (1-5) | Points | Justification Knowledge and skill | [__] | [__] | [__] | [__] Problem solving | [__] | [__] | [__] | [__] Responsibility and impact | [__] | [__] | [__] | [__] Working conditions | [__] | [__] | [__] | [__] Total points: [__] Grade: [__] Pay range: from [__] to [__] Decision: [approved / reconsider] Committee chair's signature: ________
03Notes on the clauses of the policy
Clause 1: the job, not the person
The commonest way to spoil job evaluation is to confuse an outstanding employee's job with the value of his job. An outstanding employee in a simple job is rewarded by the annual appraisal and a raise, not by lifting the grade of his job. The grade stays a description of what the job requires of any holder.
Clause 2: four factors are enough for a small company
Complex methods have twenty factors and need a consultant. For a small company four factors with weights that management announces are enough to tell a cashier from a branch manager. What matters is that each rating level is explained in a written description so two people reach the same number.
Clause 3: points become a grade by a scale
If we said a job was "close to Grade 4" we would fall into guesswork. An approved scale makes the grade boundaries known numbers, so you know that a job with 345 points is in Grade 3 unless the scale or a rating changes. If boundaries in points seem rigid, the committee reviews borderline cases and records them in the minutes.
Clause 4: the range and the position ratio
The range is a minimum, a maximum and a midpoint. The position ratio (an employee's pay divided by the midpoint) says where he sits in it: near 1 he is at the midpoint, and below it he is usually in the lower third. It is an indicator, not a verdict, because pay near the minimum for a new employee is normal. For the detail see building a salary scale for small companies and setting pay for a new job.
Clause 5: no offer without a frame
When a candidate is given more by individual bargaining, his colleague learns of it sooner or later. Limiting the offer to the grade's range is what protects the company from this kind of dispute. For differences in pay see the equal opportunity policy.
Clause 6: review keeps the scale alive
A job whose duties have changed over three years should not stay in its old grade. An appeal against an evaluation is useful for finding a job that was neglected.
Clause 7: the scale is internal
Publishing pay ranges to everyone is a management decision. What the company needs to protect is the individual's pay.
04An example: a job with 345 points
A job was evaluated on four factors with weights 35, 25, 25 and 15 (totalling 100), and ratings 4, 3, 4 and 2 out of 5:
| Factor | Weight | Rating | Points |
|---|---|---|---|
| Knowledge and skill | 35 | 4 | 140 |
| Problem solving | 25 | 3 | 75 |
| Responsibility and impact | 25 | 4 | 100 |
| Working conditions | 15 | 2 | 30 |
The total is 345 points out of 500 (69%), so the job is in Grade 3, which starts at 250 points, and it is 5 points short of the next grade (350). The grade's range runs from SAR 7,000.00 to SAR 11,000.00 with a midpoint of SAR 9,000.00. An employee whose basic pay is SAR 8,100.00 has a position ratio of 0.9 of the midpoint. If we assume housing of 25% of basic pay, it is SAR 2,250.00 at the midpoint, the employer's insurance share for a Saudi is SAR 1,434.38, and the monthly cost of the job at the midpoint is SAR 12,684.38. These are illustrative inputs. Adding up points, choosing the grade and the position ratio are simple arithmetic on the example's inputs, and the insurance share uses the program's insurance calculator function.
05When this policy is not applied
A company with only a few jobs
A company of ten employees with six jobs may do with a simple table of three grades without points, recording the reasons for differences in minutes.
Pay the law sets
What the law provides on wages, allowances and the dates they are paid is applied as it stands and does not fall under the grade scale. For the detail see the definition of wages.
The yearly appraisal of performance
A performance bonus and the yearly raise are not set by the grade of the job alone but by the employee's appraisal result.
06Difficult cases and common mistakes
An employee paid above the maximum of his grade
The cause is studied: rare experience or an old contract. His pay is not cut, and his raises are frozen until he is back inside the range, as management decides and as his contract provides.
Two similar jobs in two different grades
Either the descriptions really differ or the committee evaluated by different standards. The ratings are compared factor by factor again.
Common mistake: evaluating without a job description
Evaluation by title and not by duties gives unstable grades. Write the description first. For the writing see a job description that draws the right candidate.
Common mistake: a grade for every person
When a new grade is made for an employee asking for a raise, the scale loses its meaning. The grade belongs to the job, and a raise comes from performance inside the range.
Common mistake: a range never checked against the market
A range set three years ago has fallen below the market and candidates walk away. Review it yearly.
07Steps to adapt the policy to your company
- 1
Write the descriptions first
For each job a description of its duties, responsibilities and conditions.
- 2
Choose the factors and weights
Four factors with weights totalling 100, and a written description of each rating level from 1 to 5.
- 3
Evaluate a sample of jobs
Begin with ten varied jobs and compare the results with your instinct before extending it.
- 4
Set the scale and the ranges
Grade boundaries in points, and a minimum and maximum for each grade from market data and from your own pay.
- 5
Place the current employees
Work out each employee's position ratio and take the cases outside the range to a written decision.
08Job evaluation policy checklist before approval
9 items
09Frequently asked questions
We give no legal ruling here. The policy is a management practice that organises pricing, and what the law provides on wages is applied as it stands.
Often three to five. The fewer there are, the easier they are to manage, and the company adds grades when many similar jobs accumulate.
No single ratio is right. A new employee may start near 0.8 and rise to 1.0 and above with experience and performance. The company sets its own policy on progression.
The policy does not provide for cutting existing pay. The usual course is to freeze raises or tie them to a change of job. What is lawful in changing pay is for a specialist to decide.
The range in the template is for basic pay, and allowances are worked out by ratios or amounts the company adopts. The difference is set out in types of allowances.
By adding pay, allowances, the employer's share of insurance and whatever medical insurance and benefits are added. For the detail see working out total employee cost.
